All posts

Nov 19, 2026

Choosing a Foodservice Contract: IFB or RFP?

Lowest price or best overall fit? When it comes to selecting a foodservice provider, those aren’t always the same thing. Understanding the difference between an Invitation for Bid (IFB) and Request for Proposal (RFP) can help your school determine what matters most when evaluating vendors and choosing a foodservice partner.

Justin Kilmer in warehouse putting box of food in cart
Every five years, MDE requires Minnesota schools (or sponsors) with Vended Meal/Foodservice Management contracts to go through a full, open, competitive procurement process to establish a new contract. If your school is approaching its fifth year, you may already be thinking about what’s next and have questions. Or if you’re a few years away, now is a good opportunity to understand the process and what options you’ll have when the time comes.

One of the biggest decisions – and most common question we get – is choosing between two formal procurement methods: an Invitation for Bid (IFB) or a Request for Proposal (RFP). Both allow sponsors to competitively solicit foodservice vendors, but they differ in how proposals are evaluated and how the final contract is awarded.

Key Differences Between an IFB and an RFP

Invitation for Bid (IFB): Contract awarded based solely on price

With an IFB, the contract is awarded to the qualified bidder offering the lowest price, regardless of other factors or preferences.

Request for Proposal (RFP): Contract awarded based on price and other evaluation criteria

An RFP allows sponsors to evaluate price alongside other factors that matter to their foodservice program. Following a 100-point scale, sponsors can choose the evaluation criteria and number of points assigned to each as long as price is assigned the most points. 

When Choosing an RFP Makes Sense

For many schools, a successful foodservice program involves more factors than only meal costs. An RFP allows sponsors to adjust their evaluation criteria based on their program’s specific needs and priorities and evaluate vendors against those expectations with the goal of selecting the best overall fit.

The 100-point evaluation system is an important part of this method. To repeat, the total assigned points must equal 100 and price must represent the highest number of points awarded. 

Below is an example of what to think through when building your own evaluation criteria and assigning points. This is by no means our recommendation, but rather an illustrative explanation.

Evaluation Criteria Maximum Points
Price (reminder: this must be the greatest amount of points)  30
Criteria related to breakfast and lunch menus 29
Criteria related to ordering process 15
Criteria related to delivery process 15
… …
… …
… …
Total Points 100

Note: Non-price criteria can come in at one point below price, just as long as price remains the highest point value.

Another example comes from the former Executive Director and Food & Nutrition Director at Career Pathways, one of CKC Good Food’s partners, and directly navigating the procurement process herself. They used the RFP method to be able to evaluate factors beyond price. It resulted in finding the best vendor to meet their goals for both price and the other key areas they valued most.

Overall, using the RFP method can sometimes lead to the best vendor being the lowest bidder, but sometimes they are not.

Learn More from MDE

It’s up to each sponsor to determine what matters most to their school and select the procurement method that best fits the needs, priorities and program requirements. 

MDE is the authority on procurement rules. They provide procurement instructions, templates, contract documents and additional resources that sponsors must follow.

Some helpful resources (all updated in 2026) to learn more and get you more familiar with the process: 

For questions about the procurement process, contact MDE’s Food and Nutrition Service at mde.fsmc@state.mn.us.

Best Time to Get Started

Our biggest piece of advice is to start now. If your school needs a new food service contract for 2027-28, we recommend getting the procurement process going early in the winter and no later than early spring.

With many Minnesota schools undergoing the process at the same time, MDE can get busy reviewing procurement submissions, and the approval process can take a while. Getting started early can help you receive responses, work through the required steps and secure approval sooner. In past years, some schools have waited until summer to receive approval, leaving less time to finalize plans before the school year begins.


Here at CKC Good Food, we value the opportunity to collaborate with school communities and provide not just meals but also service and support that help food programs thrive. Whether you’re preparing for your next contract or planning ahead, we’re always happy to work together and be part of the process.